By Steve Goodier
Po Bronson, in his book WHY DO I LOVE THESE PEOPLE? (Random
House, 2005), tells a true story about a magnificent elm tree.
The tree was planted in the first half of the 20th Century on a
farm near Beulah, Michigan (USA). It grew to be a magnificent
In the 1950s, the family that owned the farm kept a bull chained
to the elm. The bull paced around the tree, dragging a heavy iron
chain with him, which scraped a trench in the bark about three
feet off ground. The trench deepened over the years, though for
whatever reason, did not kill the tree.
After some years, the family sold the farm and took their bull.
They cut the chain, leaving the loop around the tree and one link
hanging down. Over the years, bark slowly covered the rusting
Then one year, agricultural catastrophe struck Michigan in the
form of Dutch Elm Disease. It left a path of death across vast
areas. All of the elms lining the road leading to the farm became
infected and died. Everyone figured that old, stately elm would
be next. There was no way the tree could last, between the
encroaching fungus and its chain belt strangling its trunk.
The farm's owners considered doing the safe thing: pulling it out
and chopping it up into firewood before it died and blew over
onto the barn in a windstorm. But they simply could not bring
themselves to do it. It was as if the old tree had become a
family friend. So they decided to let nature take its course.
Amazingly, the tree did not die. Year after year it thrived.
Nobody could understand why it was the only elm still standing in
Plant pathologists from Michigan State University came out to
observe the tree. They observed the scar left by the iron chain,
now almost completely covered by bark and badly corroded.
The plant experts decided that it was the chain that saved the
elm's life. They reasoned that the tree must have absorbed so
much iron from the rusting chain, that it became immune to the
It's said that what doesn't kill you will make you stronger. Or,
as Ernest Hemingway put it, "Life breaks us all, but afterwards,
many of us are strongest at the broken places."
The next time you're in Beulah, Michigan, look for that beautiful
elm. It spans 60 feet across its lush, green crown. The trunk is
about 12 feet in circumference.
Look for the wound made by the chain. It serves as a reminder
that because of our wounds, we can have hope! Our wounds can give
us resources we need to cope and survive. They can truly make us
Steve Goodier's books & newsletter: